Netduma Fraser

What precisely are all the issues you're having? You mentioned a couple in other topics but I want to ensure you've put them all here so we can go through them properly

No DNS doesn't have an impact on game performance

Good to hear! DNS won't make a difference for gaming so unnecessary to change it. There isn't a backup settings function currently but it has been requested so may come in future.

It's using servers provided by: https://speed.measurementlab.net/#/ As is shown on their site: "We are temporarily running multiple tests back to back to calibrate new measurement protocols. This means results may take a little longer to appear than usual." and generally their servers are not always available/the closest to you. I'd suggest adjusting Congestion Control manually instead to achieve the same effects (Ping Optimizer just changes these percentages). You can find it in Ping Optimizer > Advanced. We suggest starting at 70% and fine tuning based on your experience.

I'll pass your comments along to the team for when they consider new hardware. We do like to keep the price point around the same though so it really depends on hardware cost.

What is the firmware version you're on currently?

Added https://forum.netduma.com/forum/151-netduma-r3-early-access/

What's your exact physical home setup and how is it set to allow the XR to have direct access to the internet? This is a NTGR feature so we're not as knowledgeable on it but we'll do what we can to help

There won't be no. It'll just be security fixes then, it's unlikely it's based on 3.3, I think it probably reached end of service before they did it.

Good to hear, don't forget the Early Access firmware as well

Thanks for the report, I'll pass it on to the team to update it

That's normal, follow this guide to see if you have a CG-NAT https://support.netduma.com/docs/dumaos-3/open-nat/#cg-nat

You shouldn't have a double NAT if the R3 is in the EE hub DMZ so I'd suggest checking the WAN IP on the R3 is the same as the IP entered in the DMZ. In that scenario if you need PPPoE for example then yes you can just put those details in and leave everything else the same. You may need to fine tune your Congestion Control settings a little more to get the same results you're used to but otherwise it would be fine. I would look into the DMZ thing though first as you can see reduced speeds and there is also a disconnect issue with PPPoE we're looking into. The R3 won't change any settings unless you change them so no need to screenshot. If you have a double NAT even after connecting to the ONT then you have a CG-NAT in which case you only have these options to resolve it: Get a static public IP from the ISP (usually a charged extra) Use a VPN (using a VPN generally gives you a moderate/strict NAT anyway, also an extra charge) Change ISP to one that doesn't use CG-NAT

Added

Good to hear, thanks for the update!

Results definitely won't be the same with the same settings due to having another router connected but you will be able to achieve the same results you'd just need to fine tune the settings. I'd be interested to see your results from all your tests

What does better results actually mean though, in what sense?

Sorry to hear that! We don't give out any ETAs but hopefully not much longer for one

Added - let us know if you get the same issue on that firmware

Good to hear, thanks for the update!

Do this: Quit the application/game/client completely - including the game client from the System Tray - important! Remove device from the Geo-Filter Give your PC the PlayStation Device Type in the Device Manager Resync from the Geo-Filter Map menu Re-add the device to the Geo-Filter Set up the Geo-Filter how you like Wait 2 minutes Boot up application/game/client and try again

Better in what sense though? PPPoE is just the way you connect to your internet

No specific version, it's something we've mentioned quite a few times before and have always recommended having the upstream ISP modem/router handle PPPoE for this reason

Please upgrade to the Early Access version and see if it still occurs - once it's fully upgraded factory reset then monitor it

Glad to hear you got it sorted, we have mentioned before there can be speed reductions with PPPoE so generally best to avoid it if you experience that