ArcaPulse Posted October 9, 2019 Author Share Posted October 9, 2019 Called ISP he reckoned the line is all over the place with dropped packets etc. but believes it's a network issue rather than a line issue. Engineer is coming first thing Friday morning (hopefully). Last time a BT engineer came he said it was an openreach problem so I don't have much hope for this one to do anything but book another engineer. I'll let you know. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 9, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 9, 2019 Okay well that is promising at least. Remove the additional routers you have as they will likely just blame them from the get go. Do keep us posted, fingers crossed. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 9, 2019 Author Share Posted October 9, 2019 To be fair to them I left both the home hub and the R1 there and they both took no notice and didn't blame the hardware. For this one though I'll definitely remove everything so that there's no excuses Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 11, 2019 Author Share Posted October 11, 2019 Engineer came, everything in the house is fine. He reckons is degradation on the copper line. He’s sent it back to BT who should call in the next couple of hours with a Special Fault Investigator appointment (don’t know if that’s just a technical name for a normal open reach engineer or if that’s a more specialised open reach engineer). He actually asked if I tried any third party routers with QOS where I showed him my massive hidden collection 😁 and said they were struggling due to the line connection. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Zennon Posted October 11, 2019 Share Posted October 11, 2019 That is good news that that they can see a fault, some folk go on for years with no resolution because of intermittent faults. Good luck with it all. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 11, 2019 Author Share Posted October 11, 2019 Unfortunately he couldn’t ‘see’ a fault as he was only allowed to work inside the house. However the tests ran by BT on the line and his report suggests there must be something wrong. He also said only gamers would notice the ping spikes and packets loss as other applications like streaming and web browsing would be unaffected so while the whole line is likely to be faulty we’re probably the only gamers on the street who bothered to report the issue so far and so I’m not super hopeful of a solution. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
magoolachub Posted October 13, 2019 Share Posted October 13, 2019 Gonna hijack this thread a little to report an issue I'm experiencing with QoS on a PPPoE/VDSL connection as well Basically, by default after doing the initial setup of putting my speeds in to anti-bufferbloat, putting a 70% limit on dl/ul and turning the policy to always, the net effect is absolutely nothing, devices are free to dl/ul at the maximum speeds of the connection, it just doesn't work. This is regardless of whether there was any active game traffic or not and there was no difference between the "always" and "when high priority traffic detected" settings. However, after much annoyance and messing around, I found out that if I manually added a device on my network to the "Traffic Prioritization" list and selected some random service (I chose skype, none of the devices actually ever use skype) the QoS would work as intended and limit the bandwidth of the device. This is by no means a new problem, it has been this way ever since I upgraded from the old firmware to DumaOS and persisted through many factory resets. Hopefully this info is useful to others and the bugs with DumaOS and PPPoE can be rectified. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 13, 2019 Author Share Posted October 13, 2019 Quick update, Openreach engineer due tomorrow morning. However I’m not that hopeful as they missed 3 appointments last time so fingers crossed! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 14, 2019 Author Share Posted October 14, 2019 Openreach have said no issues on the line with their tests so they didn’t bother sending an engineer. BT have now said no faults as well and refuse to rebook. To be fair to them the speeds are always consistent. I’m going to leave ping plotter running on my pc for an hour or two. If it’s stable then I think the issue may be with the XR500. To further this as well, the fact that it’s rock solid when I’m home alone implies that’s there’s not an issue with the line causing packet loss or anything like that. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 15, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 15, 2019 On 10/13/2019 at 2:43 AM, magoolachub said: Gonna hijack this thread a little to report an issue I'm experiencing with QoS on a PPPoE/VDSL connection as well Basically, by default after doing the initial setup of putting my speeds in to anti-bufferbloat, putting a 70% limit on dl/ul and turning the policy to always, the net effect is absolutely nothing, devices are free to dl/ul at the maximum speeds of the connection, it just doesn't work. This is regardless of whether there was any active game traffic or not and there was no difference between the "always" and "when high priority traffic detected" settings. However, after much annoyance and messing around, I found out that if I manually added a device on my network to the "Traffic Prioritization" list and selected some random service (I chose skype, none of the devices actually ever use skype) the QoS would work as intended and limit the bandwidth of the device. This is by no means a new problem, it has been this way ever since I upgraded from the old firmware to DumaOS and persisted through many factory resets. Hopefully this info is useful to others and the bugs with DumaOS and PPPoE can be rectified. There are identified issues with PPPoE/QoS/Speeds on the R1 that we are aware of and that we'll be fixing. That does sound like it could be potential user error, though. If you could create a new topic we could see if that's the case. On 10/14/2019 at 11:26 AM, ArcaPulse said: Openreach have said no issues on the line with their tests so they didn’t bother sending an engineer. BT have now said no faults as well and refuse to rebook. To be fair to them the speeds are always consistent. I’m going to leave ping plotter running on my pc for an hour or two. If it’s stable then I think the issue may be with the XR500. To further this as well, the fact that it’s rock solid when I’m home alone implies that’s there’s not an issue with the line causing packet loss or anything like that. Has there been any update on this? What were the PingPlotter results like? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 15, 2019 Author Share Posted October 15, 2019 There’s been no change if I’m honest. I decided to return the XR500 as clearly there’s something with my connection it didn’t get on with. I’m definitely going to buy it again in the future once some of the issues are resolved and the new development milestone is reached (looking good so far with the insider info!). I’ve got some ubiquity gear, I’m going to set that up tomorrow, if it works better then I can come and tell you which protocol works better for me (I don’t know if there will actually be an improvement.) if that would interest you for future updates and tweaks? Thanks for you’re help through all of this, and do you know if Jack is back soon, I haven’t had a reply from him at the email since Tuesday last week about getting the replacement R1? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 15, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 15, 2019 Really sorry to hear that but glad that you'll be back in the future! Yes please that would be really helpful! I will chase Jack on that and get him or another colleague to respond. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 22, 2019 Author Share Posted October 22, 2019 Last update for you all regarding the new set up I have. I have the HG612 modem > edgerouter X > UniFi AP. Ive solved my connection issues by having 2 VLANs , 1 for the gaming devices and 1 for the non gaming devices. I’ve then allocated each gaming device a guaranteed bandwidth. The VLAN for non gaming devices also get guaranteed bandwidth but it’s not tied to a specific device so any device within the subnet can access the full bandwidth if no other device is using it. In terms of protocol, the gaming devices use PFIFO and the non gaming are using FQ_CODEL. Hope this may help the further development of Duma OS as the set up using an interface like yours would be soooo much easier than the hours I spent within the edgerouter interface. Let me know if you’d like any more details!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Alex Posted October 23, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 23, 2019 I like the idea of having device groups with allocated bandwidth pools. If we were to implement that on DumaOS, it might bypass the need for VLANs. You could even have a visual VLAN map which shows which device groups can see which other device groups... I'll add it to the big list of future plans. We're collecting a lot of great ideas to improve bandwidth allocation. Thanks for posting! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bert Posted October 23, 2019 Share Posted October 23, 2019 Actually you can still make your R1 usefull. Plug it in your gaming VLAN and run your devices off the R1. Switch off anti bufferbloat and QoS etc and you can still use the geofiltering capabilities. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 23, 2019 Author Share Posted October 23, 2019 Hmm I never thought of that! Great idea. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 29, 2019 Author Share Posted October 29, 2019 Sorry for resurrecting the thread a bit, but it’s been nearly 2 weeks since I’ve got a response from the netduma email address. Does anyone know what’s happening with that? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Alex Posted October 29, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 29, 2019 2 hours ago, ArcaPulse said: Sorry for resurrecting the thread a bit, but it’s been nearly 2 weeks since I’ve got a response from the netduma email address. Does anyone know what’s happening with that? Oh, you certainly shouldn't be having to wait that long. We usually respond on the next weekday. I'll search through the mailbox for your most recent email, it must have been missed. Sorry about this! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArcaPulse Posted October 29, 2019 Author Share Posted October 29, 2019 Actually it was to jack if that helps? I don’t know if he’s off sick or anything. He was arranging collection and delivery for the faulty R1 and the new one being delivered. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Administrators Netduma Alex Posted October 29, 2019 Administrators Share Posted October 29, 2019 44 minutes ago, ArcaPulse said: Actually it was to jack if that helps? I don’t know if he’s off sick or anything. He was arranging collection and delivery for the faulty R1 and the new one being delivered. I have nudged Jack to give you an update! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.