Greg_lino Posted September 24, 2025 Posted September 24, 2025 1 hour ago, KinGzzy said: Okay, let's admit that what you say is "true." Explain to us why it's better. Why an Intel card and not Marvel, for example? Why SFP? SFP+ RJ45/FIBER. Which L2/L3 switch should you choose and why does it improve your network? Why do you get better sound when you change your network card? What is bridge mode and why should you enable it? And if you don't have one, what should you do? In my post, I’m not sure if it was clear, but I mentioned that this is my case. For your situation, research and run your own tests. I switched from a Realtek onboard NIC to an Intel card with a modern chip that handles packet queues better, among other improvements. As I said before, in my case! In my setup, I went from ONU + Netduma R3 dialing PPPoE to fiber directly into the SFP port of a switch dialing PPPoE + Netduma R3 for geofilter and QoS. As I said and made clear: IN MY CASE! Why did I do this? First, because Netduma performs poorly with PPPoE. If you didn’t know that, you’re in the wrong forum! My old ONU was extremely limited, causing mini stutters and adding latency. Today, I use a switch — in my case, a Banana Pi R4 with OpenWRT installed — whose job is to manage the network and handle the PPPoE connection. About the network card improving sound: we’re not talking about audio frequency or equalizers. None of that! Honestly, it shouldn’t even need explaining; anyone familiar with networking should know this. What I’m talking about is data packets transmitted from the server to your client. A network card that handles these packets and queues better ensures that the data arrives without delay. These packets carry critical info, like enemy footsteps and shot registration. With an efficient NIC, they don’t get delayed or ignored. The card you mentioned might even be better than the Intel one I used, but in my case, the noticeable difference was switching from the Realtek onboard to the Intel i226-V.
Iced Soul Posted September 24, 2025 Author Posted September 24, 2025 5 hours ago, KinGzzy said: Bullpoopy don't listen to this advice, you'll waste money for nothing... Do you even know what QOS is? 1: Prioritize traffic 2: Distribute bandwidth fairly 3: Guarantee performance levels 4: Ensure reliability for critical services You only have one PC with an internet connection, a QOS won't do you much good. Got it, buddy. I'll consider your comments. Thanks for the tips.
Iced Soul Posted September 24, 2025 Author Posted September 24, 2025 On 9/18/2025 at 5:13 AM, Netduma Fraser said: ACC is mentioned in that link I provided but we haven't provided any more information about it just yet. You can enter the poll here to be in with a chance to test it early on if you fulfil the requirements for this early test: https://forum.netduma.com/topic/60353-answer-this-topic-to-be-in-with-the-chance-to-beta-test-a-firmware-with-new-features/ Hello! An important question, since you're not the first person I've seen mention this issue here on the forum. Regarding PPPoE, why is it still problematic on R3? This type of complaint has been around for a long time. Have you still not been able to resolve it?
Iced Soul Posted September 24, 2025 Author Posted September 24, 2025 5 hours ago, KinGzzy said: Bullpoopy don't listen to this advice, you'll waste money for nothing... Do you even know what QOS is? 1: Prioritize traffic 2: Distribute bandwidth fairly 3: Guarantee performance levels 4: Ensure reliability for critical services You only have one PC with an internet connection, a QOS won't do you much good. If you could contribute a little more, friend, I'd be extremely grateful, as I'm quite new to networking. 1. What Windows and router tools can I use to prioritize traffic, other than QoS? 2. Isn't bandwidth distribution also handled by QoS? 3. Ensure network or game performance levels? How do I guarantee network performance? The game's performance is excellent. I play at 240 fps with plenty of hardware. 4. Could you be more specific about ensuring the reliability of critical services, please? I have no idea what it is. Excuse me for my lack of familiarity with the subject.
Greg_lino Posted September 24, 2025 Posted September 24, 2025 3 hours ago, KinGzzy said: About the network card improving sound: we’re not talking about audio frequency or equalizers. None of that! Honestly, it shouldn’t even need explaining; anyone familiar with networking should know this. 2- I understood, don't worry, and I am very familiar with the network because I am currently a sysadmin. What I’m talking about is data packets transmitted from the server to your client. A network card that handles these packets and queues better ensures that the data arrives without delay. These packets carry critical info, like enemy footsteps and shot registration. With an efficient NIC, they don’t get delayed or ignored. 3 - In short, packet and delay management is actually shared at several levels: The Network Interface Card (NIC) It handles the reception and transmission of packets at the hardware level. It manages the queues of incoming/outgoing packets and applies certain optimizations (such as offloading, interrupt moderation, or buffering). A high-end network card can process packets faster, reduce latency, and prevent losses if the bandwidth is high. The Operating System (kernel network stack) The kernel (Windows, Linux, etc.) manages scheduling, buffering, and the transmission of packets at the software level. It’s the one that delivers packets to applications (your game, for example). The Network Protocol (TCP/UDP, etc.) UDP (often used for games) sends packets without delivery verification → faster but with a risk of packet loss. TCP guarantees delivery (retransmission, ordering), but adds latency. The Quality of the Network (routers, ISP, the Internet in general) Even with a good network card, if your connection is unstable, saturated, or poorly routed, you will experience latency or packet loss. If necessary, I can give you a course on how the network works from layer 1 to 7. Exactly! I totally understand what you’re saying — and yes, I know that packet management is shared across the NIC, the operating system, the protocols, and the overall network quality. You explained it perfectly. I just want to make it clear that, in my case, switching from a Realtek onboard NIC to an Intel i226-V made a noticeable difference in-game. Footsteps, shot registration, and overall smoothness improved because the Intel card handles packet queues much better than my old onboard, especially under high-speed traffic. I agree with everything you said, but sometimes practical experience highlights differences that theory alone doesn’t capture. And just to be clear: I’m not interested in any course. Even though this is just a hobby for me, my knowledge isn’t that bad compared to some of the so-called “specialists” on this forum. Lol. For other forum members to understand, the equipment was added and optimized gradually over time: Fiber + ONU + Netduma R3 → total disappointment. Lots of stuttering and instability, mainly because the Netduma struggles with PPPoE. Fiber + ONU + TP-Link switch (PPPoE) + Netduma → reduced the Netduma’s stuttering, but still not ideal. Static IP → left CGNAT, noticeable improvement in latency and connection stability. Switched from Realtek onboard NIC to Intel i226-V → noticeable improvement in shot registration and enemy footsteps. Data packets arrived faster, without delays. Switched from TP-Link switch to OpenWRT router (Fiber + Banana Pi SFP + Netduma) → significant improvement in network stability. PPPoE is now handled by OpenWRT, while the Netduma takes care of QoS and Geo-Filter.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted September 25, 2025 Administrators Posted September 25, 2025 16 hours ago, Iced Soul said: Hello! An important question, since you're not the first person I've seen mention this issue here on the forum. Regarding PPPoE, why is it still problematic on R3? This type of complaint has been around for a long time. Have you still not been able to resolve it? Most of the issues with PPPoE that we've had in the past have usually been with QoS on the upload side not working with it which has been resolved. The issue currently is that a small percentage of PPPoE users are experiencing disconnects, this is most likely due to the nature of the connection method (i.e. that it 'logs' in to the internet service and can have a timeout on it) but we will fix that. Krush and Iced Soul 2
Iced Soul Posted September 26, 2025 Author Posted September 26, 2025 21 hours ago, Netduma Fraser said: Most of the issues with PPPoE that we've had in the past have usually been with QoS on the upload side not working with it which has been resolved. The issue currently is that a small percentage of PPPoE users are experiencing disconnects, this is most likely due to the nature of the connection method (i.e. that it 'logs' in to the internet service and can have a timeout on it) but we will fix that. I understand. However, this login timeout issue isn't new either. Why is it taking so long to resolve it? I think my PPPoE is like that. My R3 arrives today, and it's going to be frustrating to go through this.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted September 27, 2025 Administrators Posted September 27, 2025 19 hours ago, Iced Soul said: I understand. However, this login timeout issue isn't new either. Why is it taking so long to resolve it? I think my PPPoE is like that. My R3 arrives today, and it's going to be frustrating to go through this. It is new in that it's never been an issue before with us. We're working on some big features at the moment which is taking up a lot of resources, bugs are still being fixed but they'll come with the features in the next update. In most cases people can have their original ISP modem/router handle PPPoE instead so they don't have the issue. Also just because you are using PPPoE doesn't mean that will happen.
Iced Soul Posted October 5, 2025 Author Posted October 5, 2025 On 9/27/2025 at 4:55 AM, Netduma Fraser said: It is new in that it's never been an issue before with us. We're working on some big features at the moment which is taking up a lot of resources, bugs are still being fixed but they'll come with the features in the next update. In most cases people can have their original ISP modem/router handle PPPoE instead so they don't have the issue. Also just because you are using PPPoE doesn't mean that will happen. Ok, my friend. PPPoE worked for me. In two weeks, it disconnected a couple of times, forcing me to restart the router. However, the Geo-Filter never works. I even went to a server in Japan. That's absurd, in my opinion. I set my country as the country, and yet I'm constantly being redirected to international servers, forcing me to play with a 90-140ms ping. It's simply unplayable, with packet loss, overshooting, and everything else. One of the reasons I bought Duma R3 was to stop playing on international servers, and nothing has changed for me. How do I fix this? Another issue: the Ping Optimizer doesn't work. It pretends to find my real ping, increasing it by 15ms, and then claims to have optimized it to the value it actually is. How do I fix this? Thank you.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 5, 2025 Administrators Posted October 5, 2025 26 minutes ago, Iced Soul said: Ok, my friend. PPPoE worked for me. In two weeks, it disconnected a couple of times, forcing me to restart the router. However, the Geo-Filter never works. I even went to a server in Japan. That's absurd, in my opinion. I set my country as the country, and yet I'm constantly being redirected to international servers, forcing me to play with a 90-140ms ping. It's simply unplayable, with packet loss, overshooting, and everything else. One of the reasons I bought Duma R3 was to stop playing on international servers, and nothing has changed for me. How do I fix this? Another issue: the Ping Optimizer doesn't work. It pretends to find my real ping, increasing it by 15ms, and then claims to have optimized it to the value it actually is. How do I fix this? Thank you. We'll fix the PPPoE issue, thanks for letting us know. Disable Geo-Latency and Ping Assist, make sure you're enabling the Geo-Filter before you launch the game/client and if you change Geo-Filter settings while on the game then reboot the game and it should all stay within your radius. We're aware Ping Optimizer isn't 100% reliable currently but the ping at the start is your base ping - the ping you have before you do anything on the internet so it's established what that is to the server it is using (the ping won't be the same as wherever you may see your ping). It then simulates a heavily used network and re-tests the ping, this is where you'll see an increase in the ping. It then repeats the tests but adjusts the Congestion Control percentages to find the percentages that allow you to have a heavily used network with minimal difference in your ping. So what you described is the optimal outcome and exactly what you want it to be doing. Iced Soul 1
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 13 hours ago, Netduma Fraser said: We'll fix the PPPoE issue, thanks for letting us know. Disable Geo-Latency and Ping Assist, make sure you're enabling the Geo-Filter before you launch the game/client and if you change Geo-Filter settings while on the game then reboot the game and it should all stay within your radius. We're aware Ping Optimizer isn't 100% reliable currently but the ping at the start is your base ping - the ping you have before you do anything on the internet so it's established what that is to the server it is using (the ping won't be the same as wherever you may see your ping). It then simulates a heavily used network and re-tests the ping, this is where you'll see an increase in the ping. It then repeats the tests but adjusts the Congestion Control percentages to find the percentages that allow you to have a heavily used network with minimal difference in your ping. So what you described is the optimal outcome and exactly what you want it to be doing. I didn't find what you're telling me with the identical description. I took a screenshot and would like to ask you to please describe the route to me, as it's identified in DumaOS. Is there something wrong with my settings? An important thing to note is that on the Geo-Filter screen, when I click on the Host, it says I'm playing, even though the game isn't even open. What is the role of this host if it's different from my city? Another question. Under "Selected Game," it says "All Games." How do I put Call of Duty there?
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 1 hour ago, Iced Soul said: I didn't find what you're telling me with the identical description. I took a screenshot and would like to ask you to please describe the route to me, as it's identified in DumaOS. Is there something wrong with my settings? An important thing to note is that on the Geo-Filter screen, when I click on the Host, it says I'm playing, even though the game isn't even open. What is the role of this host if it's different from my city? Another question. Under "Selected Game," it says "All Games." How do I put Call of Duty there? Geo-Latency/Ping Assist is in your first picture which you've disabled so that's good, just make sure to load in the way I mentioned. As your PC is set as a console in Device Manager (which I would recommend you keep so that the Geo-Filter does say All Games, having it selected for just CoD may reduce its effectiveness) it may pick up other things that are using ports above 1024 which is likely why you see a server there. I can't see what your Congestion Control settings are, you'd have to scroll down more on that window.
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 30 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: Geo-Latency/Ping Assist is in your first picture which you've disabled so that's good, just make sure to load in the way I mentioned. As your PC is set as a console in Device Manager (which I would recommend you keep so that the Geo-Filter does say All Games, having it selected for just CoD may reduce its effectiveness) it may pick up other things that are using ports above 1024 which is likely why you see a server there. I can't see what your Congestion Control settings are, you'd have to scroll down more on that window. This screen here? See, the host has now placed me in Africa.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 19 minutes ago, Iced Soul said: This screen here? See, the host has now placed me in Africa. That's right yes - 30% is super low, I'd be surprised if it needed to be that low, set it to 70% each for download & upload and see if that performs better. That's a mislocated server, should be Brazil by the looks of the ID. Was the game & game client (e.g. Steam etc) closed completely, including from the System Tray and then the Geo-Filter was enabled before you launched them?
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 3 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: That's right yes - 30% is super low, I'd be surprised if it needed to be that low, set it to 70% each for download & upload and see if that performs better. That's a mislocated server, should be Brazil by the looks of the ID. Was the game & game client (e.g. Steam etc) closed completely, including from the System Tray and then the Geo-Filter was enabled before you launched them? I didn't close the game client. I'm playing through Game Pass. I'll try 70%. Are all my other settings correct?
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 20 minutes ago, Iced Soul said: I didn't close the game client. I'm playing through Game Pass. I'll try 70%. Are all my other settings correct? Make sure to close that completely including from the system tray. Everything else looks fine
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 27 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: Make sure to close that completely including from the system tray. Everything else looks fine I believe I did exactly as you instructed me to do and again I ended up on an international server.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 Have you put your PC in the DMZ or done any port forwarding rules or internet rules?
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 2 hours ago, Netduma Fraser said: Have you put your PC in the DMZ or done any port forwarding rules or internet rules? I put my PC in the DMZ
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 5 minutes ago, Iced Soul said: I put my PC in the DMZ That's probably why then, take that out and check again after rebooting the PC. It's also a major security issue putting your PC in the DMZ, you should never do it.
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 6 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: That's probably why then, take that out and check again after rebooting the PC. It's also a major security issue putting your PC in the DMZ, you should never do it. Should I use UPnP only? Is putting my PC in the DMZ preventing Geo-Filter from working properly? The Geo-Filter will work if it's in UPnP?
Krush Posted October 6, 2025 Posted October 6, 2025 DMZ + PC = WARNING ! Ne jamais/jamais.... faire ça ! Iced Soul 1
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 16 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: That's probably why then, take that out and check again after rebooting the PC. It's also a major security issue putting your PC in the DMZ, you should never do it. Just to get ahead of myself, I only set it to UPnP and still ended up on a server with an 110ms ping, outside my country.
Administrators Netduma Fraser Posted October 6, 2025 Administrators Posted October 6, 2025 11 minutes ago, Iced Soul said: Just to get ahead of myself, I only set it to UPnP and still ended up on a server with an 110ms ping, outside my country. I suspected so yes, you can use UPnP or port forwarding just not the DMZ. Is it just that server in the same location everytime or other servers in other locations outside your radius?
Iced Soul Posted October 6, 2025 Author Posted October 6, 2025 4 minutes ago, Netduma Fraser said: I suspected so yes, you can use UPnP or port forwarding just not the DMZ. Is it just that server in the same location everytime or other servers in other locations outside your radius? I set it to simple, and I'm still getting dropped on international servers. In the Host option, São Paulo appears correctly this time.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now