Moderate nat type on pc and ps5

[Westy147]

Had this problem before fraser fixed it I have now updated my netduma and have moderate nat type again unable to join private lobbies on call of duty etc

[Netduma Fraser]

Have you followed all the steps you did previously? Did you factory reset after the update?

[Westy147]

Everything was still the same and no I haven't 

[Netduma Fraser]

Do a factory reset when you have time as it'll be a significant change from previous versions then follow the same steps. It's possible that the IP of the router has changed so if you set it in the DMZ on your modem it may not apply until you update the IP there.

[Westy147]

Is this the ip on ip config ipv4 thanks 

[Netduma Fraser]

The IP shown in Settings > WAN, on the router

[Westy147]

On the netduma it begins with 87 I have not option on the virgin hub to change this 

[Westy147]

Just tried to change the duma ip to static but then get no Internet 

[Westy147]

Manged to fix it thanks 

[Netduma Fraser]

Great to hear that, thanks for the update!

[Westy147]

I have a moderate nat type again haven't changed anything same static ip assigned on duma and router but it turns moderate 

[Netduma Fraser]

Have you rebooted the R3 or the modem?

[Westy147]

I have after it changed to moderate

[Netduma Fraser]

Okay but not prior? Could you check the IP on the R3 and the IP in the DMZ on the ISP router? If this is happening once or twice a week if could be the ISP router renewing IPs and therefore giving the R3 a different IP

[Westy147]

I have found it is my pc changing ip this time never happened before 

[Netduma Fraser]

Set a reserved IP for it in Settings > DHCP and that'll prevent the PC doing that again

[Westy147]

Thank you 

[satinghostrider]

On 2/16/2024 at 6:50 AM, Netduma Fraser said:

Set a reserved IP for it in Settings > DHCP and that'll prevent the PC doing that again

Fraser, I've noticed even doing that has NAT set to moderate intermittently. Once I restart my PC, it almost always goes back to open NAT. 

[mohands]

Me too on Xbox Series X after update 41. I did all the steps, and did reset 2 times. Still Getting Moderate nat type.

[Netduma Fraser]

7 hours ago, satinghostrider said:

Fraser, I've noticed even doing that has NAT set to moderate intermittently. Once I restart my PC, it almost always goes back to open NAT. 

5 hours ago, mohands said:

Me too on Xbox Series X after update 41. I did all the steps, and did reset 2 times. Still Getting Moderate nat type.

For both of you this is with a static/reserved IP set for your devices?

[satinghostrider]

3 hours ago, Netduma Fraser said:

For both of you this is with a static/reserved IP set for your devices?

Mine is set to static/reserved IP and I find the upnp trigger kinda flaky. But a reboot of my PC usually solves it. I don't find the need to reboot the router. Hope this helps. 

[Westy147]

Is there away to have the same rule for ps5 and pc I now have a open nat on pc by portforwarding 3074 I also need the same rule for my ps5 to have a open nat 

[Netduma Fraser]

2 hours ago, Westy147 said:

Is there away to have the same rule for ps5 and pc I now have a open nat on pc by portforwarding 3074 I also need the same rule for my ps5 to have a open nat 

For multiple devices you would have to port forward 3074 for one device and then 3075 for the other device and they can then both get an open NAT

[satinghostrider]

9 hours ago, Netduma Fraser said:

For multiple devices you would have to port forward 3074 for one device and then 3075 for the other device and they can then both get an open NAT

I would like to add if I Port Forward TCP/UDP 3074 I never ever have a problem with NAT. It always shows OPEN.

So I know it is something to do with UPNP Trigger not working as intended consistently. I hope this can be fixed.

[Netduma Fraser]

11 hours ago, satinghostrider said:

I would like to add if I Port Forward TCP/UDP 3074 I never ever have a problem with NAT. It always shows OPEN.

So I know it is something to do with UPNP Trigger not working as intended consistently. I hope this can be fixed.

We are looking into improving UPnP so yes should be resolved soon