I would like to know if you have solved the QoS management of a VLAN/PPPoE connection. since QoS hasn't worked on these connections for years. Thank you!
I don't consider the test on waweform reliable because it bypasses the QoS. I don't know why but it manages to take the whole band.
on dlsreport it respects the QoS settings and in download I have 4-5 ms more in load. A great result. Unfortunately I'm reading on the web that many routers have problems with QoS on the upload side.
I applied for the beta test and I'm waiting for them to put me in, maybe it's a firmware problem.
Or I wait for the answer of some expert on the forum for a solution.
the feeling is that the QoS does not decrease the upload bandwidth, while the download seems to have been decreased precisely. in the bufferbloat test, on the other hand, I don't see any speed changes if not minimal.
I'm trying various settings to improve bufferbloat via QoS.
-xr500 is connected directly to the external ont provided by the isp (Nokia G-010G-Q)
-All tests were carried out with wifi disabled because I can play even without all devices connected.
-my connection is in FTTH vodafone gigabit. speedtest: 930 Down/ 220 Up - 14 ms ping (I live 400km far from the best server)
I am attaching results and settings.
results without and with QoS
The results are similar even if you enable or disable "Share Excess"
considerations:
-if I increase the bandwidth in download it is practically the same as the test without QoS.
-any band I put in the upload the result doesn't change.
-I have removed any energy saving from the network card (Intel I225-V) if anyone knows the optimal settings for this card, I gladly accept them.
I think I can improve the result also because it is not stable on (15ms in load) many times it is on 22-25ms very similar to the test without QoS.
What do you think and what can I try to improve the situation?